Fighting mythical battles

Banned Books Week? How about Banned Resources Week? Overzealous internet filtering keeps students away from resources in the same way that censorship keeps books out of their hands–that’s the argument of this great post from WNY Education Associates.

No, I don’t want little kids to be exposed to pornography or graphic violence.  But isn’t there some kind of happy medium? Take, for example, the website of Dr. Temple Grandin, noted author & speaker on living with autism.  She herself is autistic.  For no good reason I can see, her website is blocked by at least one widely used internet filter.

A quote from the blog post I linked to above: “I would guess that engaging in mythical battles allows us to construct all sorts of impressive armor.”  Wholesale internet filtering gives people a toasty, safe, St. George kind of feeling, as if they’ve slain the dragons of privacy invasion, online predation, and dangerously different ideas.  But if all sites with any kind of chat or social interaction are banned, how do students learn to protect personal information? Kids who are never taught to think about their online profiles are the ones who will lose out on job opportunities when potential employers view ill-considered posts or compromising photos.  If students are banned from e-mail at school, who teaches them what to do with the unlovely spam they get? And if teachers, counselors, and administrators can’t access Facebook or other social sites from school computers, how will they even know if cyberbullying, suicidal intentions, or threats of violence or  have been posted by their students?

As Angela points out, the sense of security is a false one, anyway.  If you’re never taught to recognize danger, you won’t know it when you see it.

Here’s a great quote from a fantasy novel by Lois McMaster Bujold.  Her novels have nothing to do with internet filtering, but the words are right on target nonetheless:  innocence based in ignorance is unfit to protect itself.


One response to “Fighting mythical battles

  1. That’s a beautiful point. Leave it to an author to articulate it so well. Thanks for reading and the mention here–it’s so important to assess the intentions behind the filters and to determine whether or not our practices truly achieve what we intend them to.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s